• Home
  • About Us
    • Who We Follow
  • Destinations
    • Africa
    • Asia
      • China
    • Australia
    • Central America
    • Europe
    • Middle East
    • North America
    • South America
    • Oceania
  • Travel Blog
  • Travel Tips
  • World Photos
  • Contact
    • Advertise

The Traveller World Guide | Best Travel Tips and Vacation.

Are Guidebooks Killing Our Experiences?

Travel Blog - Ross French - March 25, 2012

guidebook

By: Hogga

guidebookLonely Planet guidebooks have saved my life on several occasions. Whether I’m lost and need one of the handy maps they provide or I can’t find a hostel online that isn’t booked up, those books are my savior.

But what happens to those spots that are loved for their lack of popularity?

Whether it be a less known hostel with awesome hammocks or a waterfall to swim in that no one knows about.  As soon as these hidden gems are published in one of the many guidebooks, they become a place that everyone visits; a tourist hot spot.

Recently in Liberia, Costa Rica I visited a few waterfalls. One of them was filled with tourists and the other three were empty. When I asked why the one waterfall was so busy, the guide replied, “This place used to be empty, maybe a few locals the odd time, but as soon as it was recommended by a guidebook, there’s always 20 tourists swimming in it ever day.”

What’s your opinion? We have to understand that the writers of these guidebooks have a job to do and that is to find the best places to see in a country. But is it enhancing or ruining our experiences?

 0 8

Share This Post!

About Author / Ross French

8 Comments

  • Katrina March 25, 2012 at 11:04 AM

    I guess the next question is: are travel bloggers doing the same thing? I mean, we’d have to be pretty frickin’ popular to have the impact that a guidebook would, but still – we love to explore and blab, so…?

    Reply
  • Margyle March 25, 2012 at 11:05 AM

    I guess it depends on your point of view… if you’re someone looking for tips on a sweet spot and don’t know where to start/don’t feel like going off the beaten path (which, let’s be honest, isn’t always a good idea for safety sake) then these revelations are a totally worth it. But if you’re one of those people who hate crowds, like your own secret oasis or hate to see something get cheapened or damaged due to a glut of commercialism, then yeah, it sucks.
    But I mean, the world is a huge place and there are tons of things to see and it’s hard to know where to go – guidebooks help and to the same extent, travel blogs and other online forums do the same thing. Actually, be thankful that the one waterfall was full – probably kept most tourists distracted and away from your secret waterfalls lol

    Reply
    • Hogga March 25, 2012 at 7:24 PM

      That’s very true! The same thing happened with a place near Blenhim, NZ where you could see the baby seals. I could hardly even get past all the families to get a picture… meh.

      Reply
  • Ayngelina March 25, 2012 at 6:04 PM

    The last time I traveled with a guidebook was in Vietnam. I would find the hostel that was recommended and then choose the one right next to it which was just as nice and half the price.

    Reply
    • Hogga March 25, 2012 at 7:23 PM

      HA! Amazing! I always find I like hostels better that aren’t in there. I’ve been to a lot of great hostels that are super busy but you can’t even find on hostelbookers or hostelworld either…

      Reply
  • Terri March 26, 2012 at 4:35 PM

    With so many options for travel information out there these days, I don’t think it’s necessarily guidebooks fault. For better or worse there will always be a tourist trail somewhere whether it’s due to or it’s one made by the local tourism business community because it it’s what they think travelers and tourists want to see. At this point, I don’t use guidebooks for finding a place to stay (but then again I don’t really stay in hostels). I hear what you’re trying to say, but I don’t think it’s the guidebooks fault completely.

    Reply
    • Hogga March 28, 2012 at 12:04 PM

      Yea, that’s a really good point. There’s a hard in between

      Reply
  • Andrew April 15, 2012 at 3:45 PM

    I think this depends on where you’re off to. I’ve tramped the banana pancake south east asian tour and you do get a bit sick and tired of the same recommendations.

    I’m in Kurdistan at the moment with a crappy old ‘Turkey’ Lonely Planet I nicked from a hostel, absolute lifesaver! When you’re not sure whether you should feel bad about not speaking Turkish, Arabic or Kurdish, being able to look silly and point to a map in a book is priceless.

    I’m changing tact on some tourist destinations though, they’re tourist destinations for a reason (be it historic, picturesque etc..) I’m finding the off the beaten track/not in the guidebook places aren’t there because.. well, because there are military tanks rolling around in the streets!

    🙂

    Reply
  • Leave a Reply Cancel Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Previous Post
    Next Post

    About Me

    About Me

    Ross French grew up outside Toronto, blah blah… he went to the University of Western Ontario for fine arts and like any degree, has since done nothing in that field. More seriously, Ross French is a travel junkie & a tech nerd with a slightly concerning love for beer & wine. he a has a great awareness of life outside the 9-5 and hopes to aspire to be a hammock bum one day.

    More

    Hand Picked Posts

    • Wildlife Safari Travel Blog, Word Travel

      Top 7 Countries in the World for Safari Holidays in 2023

      January 30, 2023
    • Rhinebeck North America, Travel Blog

      Discovering the Charm of Rhinebeck: A Journey Through Time in the Hudson Valley

      January 28, 2023
    • Beaches Near Orlando North America, Travel Blog

      The Best Beaches Near Orlando, Florida

      January 23, 2023
    • Travel Blog

      The 6 Best Souvenirs to Buy While Traveling

      January 14, 2023
    • Top Destinations Travel Blog, Travel Tips, Word Travel

      The Top Destinations Around the World to Invest in Real Estate

      January 14, 2023

    • Wildlife Safari
      Top 7 Countries in the World for Safari Holidays in 2023
    • Rhinebeck
      Discovering the Charm of Rhinebeck: A Journey Through Time in the Hudson Valley
    • Beaches Near Orlando
      The Best Beaches Near Orlando, Florida
    • The 6 Best Souvenirs to Buy While Traveling
    • Top Destinations
      The Top Destinations Around the World to Invest in Real Estate

    Follow me on Twitter

    Tweets by @worldguideblog

    Alison is a creative soft blog theme made with by angrygorilla. Shared by Themes24x7